Albany Via Media

November 25, 2011

To the Editor:

On the AVM Facebook page William Hammond is pressing the question of whether “mere attendance” by Albany clergy at same-sex marriage liturgies constitutes a violation of the canons. I do not have a final answer to that question, but I agree that it would be important to clarify the matter. I can say this:

1. I always have assumed that the canon merely prohibits the performance in such a rite either as a celebrant or assisting minister. While theologically speaking, attendance at such a service within the congregation would constitute “participation,” I never understood that to be the intent of the canon. However, while I supported the canon, and still do — I had nothing to with writing the canon or putting it forward as a resolution, so I can't speak authoritatively on the matter.

2. I am in the process of trying to get some clarity on this issue from others in the diocese, but I have not received a decisive answer yet.

3. I personally don't see how prohibiting mere attendance would be enforceable, and I doubt that the diocese would initiate disciplinary proceedings for such an action.

4. There is big difference between officiating at such a rite and “mere attendance.” While I disagree with those who favor same-sex rites, we are not the “thought police.” Even the Roman Catholic Church recognizes the integrity of individual conscience, and we, after all, are Anglicans; and, as Queen Elizabeth I said, we do not seek to put windows into men's souls and enforce “correct thought.” Just speaking for myself, I would expect and hope that attendance would be seen in this light. Perhaps, for the sake of clarity, it could be asked that clergy attending such rites within the congregation not wear cerical attire. On the other hand, this too seems unenforceable. I doubt anyone would have the will to police clerical attire at such an event. I would hope not.

These are just my own thoughts. I do think it is reasonable to seek a clarification on this matter — and also refrain from assuming the worst until an answer is obtained.

Fr. Christopher Brown